The
Supreme Court on Friday granted bail to liquor giant Pernod Ricard's executive
Benoy Babu in a money laundering case arising out of the Delhi excise policy
scam.
A
bench of Justices Sanjiv Khanna and SVN Bhatti noted that the accused has been
in custody for more than 13 months and the trial against him has still not
commenced in the case.
The
bench also noted that there were contradictions in the case probed by the CBI
and the ED with regard to Babu.
"You
can't keep people behind bars before trial for long. This is not proper. We
still don't know how this will go. There seems to be some contradiction between
what the CBI is alleging and the ED is alleging in the case," the bench
told Additional Solicitor General SV Raju, appearing for the Enforcement
Directorate (ED).
At
the outset, senior advocate Harish Salve, appearing for Babu, said it is a
completely 'bogus case' against his client which is being probed by the ED.
"As
per the ED's case, Babu met Vijay Nair (Aam Aadmi Party's communication
in-charge and accused in Delhi excise policy case) on March 27, 2021 but the
draft excise policy was already announced on March 22, 2021," the senior
lawyer said.
The
bench asked Raju about the submission of Salve to which he accepted that Babu
had indeed met Nair on March 27, 2021.
Justice
Khanna told Raju that the ED cannot put anyone behind for such a long period of
time without the trial being commenced and ordered that Babu be released on
bail in the case.
"It's
nothing but long pre-trial detention. In CBI's case he is a prosecution witness
but in ED's case he has been named as an accused," the bench said, while
directing him to be released on bail.
Babu
had challenged the July 3 order of the Delhi High Court by which his bail was
rejected in the case.
The
high court had said that there was sufficient material on the record to support
the ED's claim that Babu was indulging or knowingly assisting in the process or
activity connected with the proceeds of crime.
It
had observed that in case of a conspiracy to generate proceeds of crime, a
person who is connected with any related process or activity cannot avoid the
responsibility.
The
Delhi government had implemented the excise policy on November 17, 2021 but
scrapped it at the end of September 2022 amid allegations of corruption.
Both
Babu and Nair were arrested by the ED in November last year.