⦿
1) Guardianship and Custody – Parens Patriae Jurisdiction – The Supreme Court’s inherent jurisdiction to protect the welfare of a minor child permits granting interim custody orders, independent of statutory guardianship proceedings. 2) Child Welfare – Interim Custody – The paramount consideration in custody disputes, including across jurisdictions and differing parental nationality, is the best interests of the child assessed through factors including emotional bonds, care capacity, stability, education, and psychological wellbeing.
1) Taxation – Bombay Entertainments Duty Act, 1923, Section 2(a) – The term "entertainment" includes any exhibition to which persons are admitted for payment; the use of the word "includes" denotes an enlarging, non-exhaustive definition encompassing exhibits even if commercial or educational in nature. 2) Statutory Interpretation – Interpretation Clause – The word "includes" in a definition clause extends the scope of the defined term beyond its ordinary meaning, thereby capturing activities that may not traditionally be considered entertainment but fall within the statutory language.
1) Family Law – Custody and Visitation – Custody order under family settlement – Custody rights and visitation rights must be strictly adhered to until modified by competent authority. 2) Child Welfare – Best Interest of the Child – In custody disputes, the child's psychological well-being and inclination are critical factors for Court's consideration before enforcing custody changes.
1) Civil Procedure Code – Order I Rule 10(2) – Permission for impleadment requires demonstration that the presence of the proposed party is necessary or proper for effective adjudication. 2) Constitutional Law – Article 227 – The High Court’s supervisory jurisdiction to interfere in subordinate court’s order is limited to cases of patent jurisdictional error, perversity, or grave miscarriage of justice.
1) Criminal Procedure - Quashing of FIR - Quashing is warranted where allegations made in the FIR, even if accepted at face value, do not prima facie constitute an offence and where the criminal proceedings are manifestly malafide or an abuse of the process of law. 2) Corporate Criminal Liability - Mere association as a director does not attract criminal liability unless the director’s own active role with criminal intent is established, especially in financial disputes resolved under civil remedies.
1) Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 — Section 197(1)(a) — Prosecution of public servants — Prior sanction for prosecution is a jurisdictional precondition where the accused is a public servant not removable from office save by sanction of the government and the alleged offence is committed in discharge of official duty. 2) Criminal Procedure — Public Servants — Official Duty Nexus — The tribunal must ascertain a reasonable connection between the alleged offence and the discharge of official duty for sanction requirement to arise; mere holding of public office does not attract the provision.
1) Criminal Law – Cheating – Essential elements include deception, fraudulent inducement and dishonest intention at the inception of transaction; absence of direct nexus or inducement vitiates claim of cheating. 2) Civil Procedure & Insolvency – Pendency of civil and insolvency proceedings involving inter-creditor disputes precludes criminalization of such commercial disputes and unexplained delay in filing FIR militates against sustaining criminal prosecution.
1) Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 — Section 19 — Sanction for prosecution — Only the authority competent to remove a public servant from office can grant valid sanction to prosecute under Section 19(1)(c) — Sanction granted by an incompetent authority is void ab initio. 2) Banking Regulation Act, 1949 — Sections 5-A, 35-B(1)(b), 36-AA, 36-AC — The Reserve Bank of India has overriding power and sole competence to remove managing directors or chief executive officers of banking companies and to grant sanction for prosecution — The powers of the Board of Directors are overridden and rendered void to the extent repugnant by these provisions.
1) Criminal Law – IPC Sections 306 and 34 – Essential elements of abetment of suicide require proximate and live link of instigation or intentional aid by accused – Mere reference in suicide note insufficient without corroborative material. 2) Criminal Procedure – Power to quash FIR under inherent jurisdiction – Subsequent investigation outcomes and judicial discharge order in related offences can be material to consider quashing where no prima facie case is made out.
1) PMLA – Sections 2(1)(u) and 3 – Jurisdiction to prosecute under PMLA arises only upon existence of proceeds of crime derived from criminal activity relating to a scheduled offence; quashing of the predicate scheduled offence FIR extinguishes jurisdiction unless a legally sustainable independent scheduled offence is shown. 2) Indian Penal Code – Sections 415, 420, 120-B, 419, 467, 471 – Essential ingredients of cheating and conspiracy under IPC must be established by demonstration of deception, dishonest inducement, and agreement directed to a scheduled offence before invoking PMLA jurisdiction based on such charges.
1) Cantonment Act and Rent Act – Extension and application – The Bombay Rent Act does not apply to premises within cantonments leased by the Government under the Cantonments (House Accommodation) Act, 1923, as modified by the Cantonments (Extension of Rent Control Laws) Act, 1957, thereby vesting jurisdiction with the civil courts under the Transfer of Property Act for disputes concerning such premises. 2) Government Grants Act, 1885 and old grant tenure – In cantonment areas, lands granted on old grant terms create only occupancy rights subject to Government’s proprietary rights and right of resumption, which exclude application of the Transfer of Property Act and bar lessees from claiming ownership or tenancy protections under usual landlord-tenant laws.
1) Electricity Act, 2003 – Section 29(4) – Decisions of Regional Power Committees in power system planning have statutory binding force on stakeholders, validating inclusion of LILOs in the transmission system and tariff determination. 2) Electricity Act, 2003 – Sections 10, 61, 79 and Central Electricity Regulatory Commission (Terms and Conditions of Tariff) Regulations, 2014, Regulation 4(3)(ii) – COD determination and liability for transmission charges depend on actual commissioning and use of elements in the transmission system; delay by generating company in commissioning dedicated transmission line can render it liable for transmission charges until such commissioning.
1) Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 – Section 37 – The power of appellate courts to interfere with arbitral awards is limited and cannot be exercised on mere subjective notions such as 'shock to conscience' without substantive justification. 2) Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 – Section 34 & 37 – Additional work similar in nature to the original contractual work, necessitated by unforeseen conditions, can be awarded provided it is supported by valid measurement and documentary evidence, notwithstanding absence of a completion certificate.
1) Criminal Law – Circumstantial Evidence – A conviction based solely on circumstantial evidence requires a complete, unbroken chain of circumstances pointing conclusively to the guilt of the accused and inconsistent with any hypothesis of innocence. 2) Indian Evidence Act, Section 27 – Recovery of stolen property at the instance of accused creates a presumption of guilt only if the recovery is proved beyond doubt and forms an integral part of the same transaction as the charge; mere possession raises presumption under Section 114 Evidence Act but cannot infer guilt for murder without direct link proving a continuous transaction.
1) Property Law – Mesne Profits – Determination – Mesne profits are compensatory in nature and must be assessed on a fair and reasonable estimate considering the nature and location of the property, prevailing rental value, and evidence of the parties. 2) Civil Procedure Code, 1908 – Order XX Rule 12 – Interest – Interest forms an integral component of mesne profits, compensating the owner for deprivation of beneficial enjoyment of property during wrongful occupation.
1) Service Law – Disciplinary Proceedings – Consent Orders and Due Process – Non-adherence to a judicially sanctioned procedure for leading evidence undermines the validity of disciplinary action. 2) Constitutional Law – Article 226 – Writ Jurisdiction – Relief under writ jurisdiction can be granted for procedural irregularities and violation of express judicial orders causing prejudice to affected employees.
1) Civil Procedure Code – Order II Rule 2 – Res judicata and constructive res judicata bar claims that could or should have been raised in earlier proceedings related to the same cause of action. 2) Civil Procedure Code – Section 151 and judicial principles – Miscellaneous applications post-final disposal have a narrow scope, limited to ancillary matters and cannot be employed for fresh or substantive relief beyond correction or clarification of the original order.
1) Constitutional Law – Right to Property and Natural Justice – Statutory procedure under Section 26 of the Control of National Highways (Land and Traffic) Act, 2002 mandates notice and hearing before removal of unauthorised encroachments, ensuring principles of natural justice are complied with. 2) Administrative Law – Judicial Directions – General directions for removal of encroachments do not substitute for statutory adjudication of rights or ownership disputes, which must be determined by competent authorities or courts with due process.
1) Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 – Section 2(2)(b) – Acquisition of land by State for private companies for public purpose requires prior consent of at least 80% of affected families obtained along with the Social Impact Assessment. 2) Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 – Section 41(3) – In Scheduled Areas, prior consent of Gram Sabha is a mandatory prerequisite before issuance of acquisition notification.
1) Criminal Law – Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 – Section 138 – Bail – The offence under Section 138 is bailable and compoundable, entitling the accused to be released on bail unless exceptional circumstances exist. 2) Criminal Procedure – Bail – The court must consider the nature of the offence, antecedents of the accused, and likelihood of absconding; prior custody in related cases and conduct demonstrating willingness to cooperate favor bail grant.
1) Criminal Law – Bail – Bail is the rule and jail the exception – This principle is constitutional, flowing from Articles 21 and 22 of the Constitution of India and the presumption of innocence; courts should guard against refusal of bail as punishment. 2) Criminal Procedure – Right to Speedy Trial – Prolonged incarceration without reasonable prospect of trial completion violates the fundamental right to a speedy trial under Article 21, warranting bail even in serious offences.
1) Jurisdiction - Review of Judgment - Review jurisdiction is confined to correcting errors apparent on the face of the record; it is not an appellate jurisdiction to re-examine merits or reconsider findings based on a different view. 2) Lease – Sub-division – Sub-division of leasehold property requires lessor’s permission; a decree between private parties cannot compel recognition of split tenancy against the lessor’s terms.
1) Constitutional Law – Goods and Services Tax (GST) – Section 7(1)(c) and Entry 2 of Schedule I of CGST Act, 2017 – Corporate guarantees furnished by holding companies to subsidiaries constitute supply of services even without consideration, with the subsidiary as the recipient. 2) Taxation – Valuation – Rule 28(2) of CGST Rules, 2017 – The prescribed deemed value of 1% per annum of the guaranteed amount is a rebuttable presumption that yields to demonstrable lower open market value; upfront valuation for entire tenure with single supply rule applies; guarantees executed before GST commencement are not taxable unless renewed or extended post 01.07.2017.
1) Commercial Courts Act, 2015 – Section 12A – Pre-Institution Mediation – A suit which contemplates urgent interim relief is exempt from the mandatory requirement of pre-institution mediation and is maintainable. 2) Civil Procedure Code, 1908 – Order XXXIX Rule 1 and Section 89 – Courts possess discretionary power to refer parties to mediation and grant interim relief including status quo pending mediation, even post institution of suit, especially to prevent frustrating the mediation process.
1) Constitutional Law – Article 14 – Discretionary Power – The discretion vested in the Central Government to impose anti-dumping duty after the Designated Authority’s recommendation is legislative/quasi-legislative in nature and must be exercised bearing a rational nexus to material facts without arbitrariness. 2) WTO Law – Agreement on Implementation of Article VI of the GATT 1994 – Article 9)1 – Anti-Dumping Duty – The decision to impose or not impose anti-dumping duty, even when dumping and injury are established, is discretionary and not obligatory, permitting a domestic two-tier institutional framework.
1) Criminal Law – Section 302 IPC – Conviction for murder requires proof beyond reasonable doubt including ocular, medical, ballistic and recovery evidence establishing culpability. 2) Sentencing – Death Penalty – Imposition governed by “rarest of rare” doctrine as laid down in Bachan Singh and Machhi Singh; aggravating and mitigating circumstances must be balanced with life imprisonment as the rule and death penalty as an exception.
1) Constitutional Law – Article 72 – Mercy Petition – President’s power to commute death sentence includes imposition of conditions such as no remission, and such power is subject to limited judicial review on grounds like mala fide exercise or arbitrariness. 2) Constitutional Law – Article 21 – Right to Life – Inordinate and unexplained delay in execution of death sentence and the pendency of Mercy Petitions cause psychological torture and violate the convict’s fundamental right to life and dignity, warranting commutation of sentence.
1) Criminal Procedure – Section 503 of Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 – Delivery of seized property to a person entitled – entitles restitution where property is wrongly released due to erroneous judicial orders. 2) Civil Procedure Code – Section 144 CPC – Principle of restitution – restoration to original position is applicable not only for erroneous court orders but also where one party’s action induces erroneous judicial relief causing loss to another.
1) Constitutional Law - Article 30(1) - Minority Educational Institutions – Aided linguistic minority institutions have the right to administer and make appointments autonomously subject to prescribed qualifications and selection procedures, and the State’s regulatory authority is limited to conditions that do not impair this right. 2) Education Law - Delhi School Education Act, 1973 and Rules – Eligibility for grant-in-aid requires compliance with applicable Recruitment Rules including prescribed minimum qualifications, sanctioned vacancies, and procedural formalities; B.Ed. alone does not satisfy the JBT/BTC requirement for Assistant Teachers under 1989 Recruitment Rules applicable to aided schools.
1) Contempt of Court – Sections 2(b), 10, 11 and 12 of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 – Wilful disobedience of a Court order including undertakings amounts to civil contempt necessitating proof of deliberate or contumacious intent to disobey. 2) Civil Procedure Code – Order XII Rule 6 and Order I Rule 10 CPC – Existence of pending civil remedies concerning title and possession preclude invoking contempt jurisdiction as a substitute for execution or adjudication of substantive disputes.
1) Civil Procedure Code – Order XXXVII Rule 3(5) – Leave to Defend – Defendant raising triable issues indicating fair defense is ordinarily entitled to unconditional leave to defend; imposing conditions is permissible only if bona fides are doubtful but such conditions must not be unduly harsh as to shut out genuine defense. 2) Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 – Section 138 – Dishonour of cheque – Dishonour and related complaint’s outcome relevant in assessing genuineness of defense in civil suit for recovery based on same transaction.
1) Transfer of Property Act, 1882 – Section 123 and 129 – Mohammedan Law – A gift of immovable property under Mohammedan Law need not be registered but must fulfill substantive requisites: declaration, acceptance, and delivery of possession. 2) Slum Areas (Improvement and Clearance) Act, 1956 – Section 19 – Protection against eviction without permission applies exclusively to tenants recognized in law, not to mere licensees, trespassers, or occupiers without tenancy rights.
1) Service Law – Discipline and Appeal – Rule 26(2) of the General Insurance (Conduct, Discipline and Appeal) Rules, 1975 mandates that if the competent authority disagrees with the Inquiry Officer’s findings on any charge, it must record reasons for disagreement, record its own findings based on sufficient evidence, and give the employee a reasonable opportunity to respond. 2) Administrative Law – Principles of Natural Justice – A disciplinary authority reversing inquiry findings must communicate tentative reasons for disagreement to the delinquent employee and afford an opportunity of hearing before recording final findings and imposing penalty.
1) Civil Procedure Code – Order XXIX Rule 2(a) – Service on Corporation – Service on a company must be effected upon its secretary, director, principal officer, or at its registered office, and service on an employee not falling under these categories does not constitute valid service. 2) Civil Procedure Code – Order VIII Rule 1 and SCG Contracts (2019) – Strict compliance with 120-day time limit for filing written statement in commercial suits is mandatory once valid service is effected.
1) Civil Procedure Code – Order XXXIX Rule 10 – Provides a specific statutory remedy of appeal under Order XLIII Rule 1 against orders passed thereunder, limiting supervisory jurisdiction under Article 227. 2) Constitutional Law – Article 227 – Supervisory jurisdiction of High Court is to be exercised sparingly and only where no efficacious alternative remedy exists.
1) Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 – Sections 138, 118 & 139 – Presumption as to consideration and discharge of debt – Cheque dishonour gives rise to presumption that cheques were issued for discharge of legally enforceable debt or liability, which the accused must rebut by cogent evidence. 2) Indian Evidence Act, 1872 – Section 65 – Secondary Evidence – Photocopy of unstamped, unnotarized lease agreement without original and no notice for original’s production is inadmissible and cannot be relied upon to disprove liability under NI Act.
1) NDPS Act – Section 37 – The bar on grant of bail applies only in cases involving commercial quantity; possession of intermediate quantity does not attract the statutory bail prohibition. 2) Constitutional Law – Article 22(1) – Arresting authority must supply written grounds of arrest to the accused in an understandable language at least two hours prior to producing the accused before a Magistrate; failure to do so vitiates the legality of arrest.
1) Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 – Section 37 – Bail under the NDPS Act requires the court to be satisfied on reasonable grounds that the accused is not guilty and is not likely to commit an offence while on bail, and the satisfaction must be based on substantial probable cause beyond prima facie view. 2) Criminal Procedure Code, 1973 – Section 439 – Bail under the NDPS Act is subject to the restrictions placed under Section 37 and the conditions under Section 439 CrPC; grant of bail is not automatic and requires careful judicial satisfaction.
1) Criminal Procedure – Anticipatory Bail – Section 482 of Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 – Bail may be granted if custodial interrogation is not necessary and applicants are cooperating with the investigation. 2) Evidence – Inference from Co-accused Statements – Mere receiving stolen property based on co-accused’s disclosure is insufficient to deny anticipatory bail if no direct incriminating evidence exists and custodial interrogation is unnecessary.
1) NDPS Act, Sections 20/25/29 and Section 37 – Bail conditions for commercial quantity cases require court satisfaction on reasonable grounds that accused is not guilty and not likely to commit offence. 2) Criminal Procedure – Prima facie satisfaction on bail application under Section 37 does not require recording of categorical guilt or innocence but a broad reasonable assessment of the evidence.
1) Criminal Procedure – Section 439 CrPC – Bail – An accused is entitled to bail if the prosecution evidence is not conclusive and the trial court must consider facts and material on record. 2) Indian Penal Code – Section 302/34 – Murder – Evidence including eyewitness testimony and video recordings are relevant but custody cannot be continued indefinitely without effective prosecution.
1) Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988, Section 7 - Establishes criminal liability for public servants accepting gratification for illegal acts, including extortion through subordinates, emphasizing the responsibility of senior officers. 2) Criminal Procedure Code - Bail principles in serious corruption cases require consideration of gravity of offence, role of accused, and potential for tampering or flight, guiding the court’s discretion to deny bail in such circumstances.
1) Criminal Procedure – Bail – The mere recovery of a weapon from an accused does not prima facie establish the offence of preparation for dacoity without corroborative evidence. 2) Evidence – Use of Call Detail Records – Mere telephonic connectivity between accused and co-accused, without intercepted communication content, is insufficient to impute criminality.
1) Criminal Procedure – Interim Bail – Grounds for grant of interim bail include genuine medical illness warranting temporary release, subject to verification of medical reports and court satisfaction. 2) Procedure – Duty of Applicant – Full disclosure of antecedent orders and truthful filing of documents including signed vakalatnama is mandatory; concealment or non-compliance may lead to dismissal of bail applications.
1) Criminal Procedure – Section 175(3) BNSS – The trial court must decide miscellaneous applications expeditiously to maintain timely administration of justice. 2) Criminal Procedure – Section 258(1) BNSS – After hearing arguments in a Sessions trial, judgment must be delivered as soon as possible, within 30 days or up to 45 days with written reasons, providing a benchmark for reasonable time frames in criminal proceedings.
1) Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 – Section 37(2)(b) – Powers of appellate court to entertain appeals against interlocutory orders passed by Arbitral Tribunal and the principle of judicial restraint pending final disposal of connected matters. 2) Arbitration Procedure – Interim Protection – Court’s discretion regarding grant, modification or suspension of interim relief during pendency of related appeals and importance of parties’ liberty to seek appropriate applications before Arbitral Tribunal.
1) Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 – Section 11 – Appointment of Arbitrator – Courts may direct the initiation of arbitral proceedings within a reasonable timeframe to ensure effective dispute resolution. 2) Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 – Section 17 and Section 9 – Interim Measures – Interim relief granted by courts before constitution of Arbitral Tribunal can be continued, varied, or vacated by the Tribunal upon its constitution.
1) Railway Claims – Section 23 of the Railway Claims Tribunal Act, 1987 – Burden of Proof – Mere absence or non-recovery of a ticket from an injured passenger does not negate the status of a bona fide passenger once initial burden is discharged by producing or verifying the ticket. 2) Evidence – Reliance on Uncross-examined Eyewitness Statements in Enquiry Reports – Statements contained in enquiry reports by persons not produced for cross-examination cannot be treated as conclusive evidence against a party.
1) Railways Act, 1989 – Section 123(c) on "untoward incident" – An accidental fall while boarding or de-boarding a train, even from the off side, constitutes an untoward incident, provided there is no intentional self-infliction. 2) Evidence – Burden of Proof – Mere absence or non-recovery of a journey ticket does not negate bona fide passenger status; initial burden on claimant to establish circumstances, thereafter shifts to Railways to rebut on preponderance of probabilities.
1) Criminal Law – IPC and POCSO Act – Sections 376D, 302, 120B, 109 IPC; Section 6 and Section 17 POCSO – Sentencing of CCL – Suspension of sentence during appeal to preserve the right to appeal unless exceptional circumstances exist. 2) Criminal Procedure – Suspension of Sentence – Appellate Court’s discretion to suspend fixed-term sentences during pendency of appeals liberally, subject to public interest and imposition of conditions, as per precedent in Bhagwan Rama Shinde Gosai v. State of Gujarat (1999) and Aasif alias Pasha v. State of U.P. (2025).
1) Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 – Section 34 – Petition under section 34 challenges the arbitral award and pending such petition, enforcement proceedings may be stayed or withdrawn at the discretion of the court. 2) Civil Procedure – Non-prosecution – Court’s inherent power to dismiss proceedings for non-prosecution if the party fails to appear despite notice and reasonable opportunity.
1) Service Law – CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965 – Rule 16(e) mandates prior consultation with UPSC for imposing certain penalties on government servants appointed through competitive examination. 2) Administrative Law – UPSC (Exemption from Consultation) Regulations, 1958, Regulation 5(2) exempts disciplinary consultation with UPSC for Defence Service civilians, including serving GREF officers.
1) Service Law – Recruitment – Seniority and Pay Fixation – A candidate wrongfully excluded from appointment is entitled to notional seniority and pay fixation from the date he should have been appointed consistent with his place in the merit list. 2) Service Law – Principles of Pay – "No Work No Pay" Rule – Actual monetary benefits and arrears cannot be claimed for the period prior to joining service even where notional seniority and pay fixation are granted.
1) Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 – Section 14 – Central Administrative Tribunal’s exclusive jurisdiction over service matters relating to civil posts under the Union, thereby ousting ordinary courts’ jurisdiction except the Supreme Court. 2) Constitutional Law – Writ Jurisdiction – Writ jurisdiction may be exercised by High Courts despite alternative remedy if fundamental rights enforcement, failure of natural justice, or jurisdictional excess is involved.
1) The 24-hour timeline under Article 22(2) begins from the time a person's liberty is curtailed by effective detention, not from the time of formal arrest.
1) Criminal Procedure – Bail – Under the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 – Section 75(2) prescribes non-bailable offence, but grant of bail is a discretionary relief subject to facts and circumstances. 2) Criminal Procedure – Bail – Compliance with Supreme Court guidelines in Arnesh Kumar v. State of Bihar ensures safeguarding the rights of the accused while considering bail applications.
1) Civil Procedure Code – Order 39 Rules 1 and 2 – Temporary Injunction – The Court shall grant temporary injunction to prevent wastage, damage, alienation, sale or disposition of property in dispute or injury to the plaintiff until disposal of the suit or further orders. 2) Civil Procedure Code – Section 151 – Inherent Powers of Court – The Court possesses inherent powers to make orders necessary for ends of justice or to prevent abuse of process, enabling expeditious hearing and disposal of interlocutory applications.
1) Service Law – Alteration of Recruitment Criteria – Eligibility and Weightage – Recruitment criteria once notified cannot be altered after commencement of the selection process unless expressly permitted by rules and consistent with non-arbitrariness under Article 14 of the Constitution. 2) Constitutional Law – Article 14 – Fairness and Transparency – Changes in recruitment rules or criteria after start of the process, not communicated beforehand, violate the fundamental right to equality and legitimate expectation of candidates.
1) Constitutional Law – Right to Life and Personal Liberty (Article 21) – Adult individuals have the right to live with their choice of partner, including live-in relationships, and such relationships are entitled to protection from violence and harassment. 2) Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 – Recognizes live-in relationships and provides a framework for protection against domestic violence for partners in such relationships.
1) Police Protection – Adult individuals who have lawfully entered into marriage voluntarily are entitled to protection from harassment and threats by family members. 2) Constitutional Law – Right to Life and Personal Liberty under Article 21 mandates State authorities to act promptly to prevent threats to life and personal safety.
1) Medical Termination of Pregnancy Act, 2021 – Section 3(2-B) provides for termination beyond 24 weeks only in case of substantial foetal abnormalities. 2) Constitutional Law – Article 21 – The right to reproductive choice includes the right to refuse abortion and to continue pregnancy, emphasizing autonomy and bodily integrity of the pregnant person.
1) Service Law – CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965 – Procedural fairness and natural justice require that an accused government servant be given reasonable opportunity including inspection of relevant documents to prepare a defence before imposing penalties. 2) Administrative Law – Adverse disciplinary action without full inquiry and ignoring relevant findings and advice on similar charges by UPSC leads to invalidation of penalty.
1) Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 – Sections 7 and 13(1)(d) – Offence under these sections requires proof of demand and acceptance of illegal gratification as a sine qua non for conviction. 2) Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 – Section 20 – Legal presumption of motive or reward arises only after foundational facts of demand and acceptance are proved by evidence; this presumption is rebuttable by accused.
1) Criminal Procedure Code – Section 389(1) – Suspension of sentence vs stay of conviction – Stay of conviction is an exceptional remedy necessitating compelling and articulated reasons, as it prevents the immediate legal consequences that arise from a conviction. 2) Constitutional Law – Article 14 (Equality before law) – Doctrine of parity mandates equal treatment of co-accused standing on the same evidentiary footing; any differential treatment must be justified by intelligible differentia with rational nexus.
1) Property Law – Transfer and Alienation – A transferee of property acquires all rights to the property including the right to receive substitute allotments and to alienate the property, subject to valid covenants – This principle governs the devolution of title from predecessors-in-interest to the first respondent. 2) Contract Law – Stipulations in Exchange Deed – Conditions attached to a failed land exchange deed do not automatically bind parties under a subsequently executed and distinct exchange deed, especially where fresh terms are agreed upon and the prior deed fails due to the Board's own fault.
1) Administrative Law – Natural Justice – The test for bias is whether there is a reasonable likelihood or reasonable apprehension of bias from the perspective of a fair-minded and informed observer, rendering the proceedings unfair and unsustainable. 2) Administrative Law – Inquiry Proceedings – Presence of close kinship between complainant, witness, and adjudicator in disciplinary inquiries gives rise to a constitutional imperative under Article 14 that no one shall be a judge in their own cause and vitiates the inquiry.
1) Criminal Procedure Code – Section 197 & Maharashtra Amendment to Section 156(3) – Protection from prosecution for acts done in discharge or purported discharge of official duty requires prior sanction, which must be granted by a competent authority within 90 days or deemed to be accorded. 2) Public Servants – Official Duty – For applicability of sanction provisions, the offence must be reasonably connected to the discharge of official duty; misusing office for criminal acts such as forgery and fabrication does not attract protection under Section 197 Cr.P.C.
1) U.P. Revenue Code, 2006 – Section 207 – Appeal – Only final orders or decrees passed in suits or proceedings are appealable; interlocutory orders rejecting applications on maintainability grounds do not confer the right to appeal. 2) U.P. Revenue Code, 2006 – Section 210 – Revision jurisdiction – The Board of Revenue’s revisional jurisdiction is limited and does not allow substituting first-instance findings or entertaining revisions against appellate orders where second appeals are provided.
1) Criminal Procedure – Bail – Conditions – Bail conditions should not be so onerous as to make the grant of bail ineffective or impossible. 2) Criminal Jurisprudence – Surety Requirement – Courts have the discretion to modify surety requirements to cash deposits for equitable relief.
1) Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960 – Section 73CA – provides that a person held responsible under Section 88 inquiry or whose Committee is superseded under Section 110-A is disqualified from being elected or nominated to the Bank’s Committee. 2) Administrative Law – Enforcement of disqualification – pendency of appeals and failure to grant stay does not entitle parties to circumvent statutory disqualification under the MCS Act.
1) Criminal Procedure – Suspension of Sentence – A conviction sentence can be suspended during the appeal process where the appellant was on bail throughout trial and the maximum punishment awarded is not excessive. 2) Bail – Conditions for Suspension – Suspension of sentence pending appeal may be granted upon furnishing personal and solvent sureties, ensuring the presence of the accused for trial completion.
1) Criminal Procedure Code – Suspension of Sentence – The court has the discretion to suspend sentence during the pendency of an appeal if it is found appropriate considering facts such as period of custody and nature of punishment. 2) Bail – Grant of Bail After Conviction – Bail may be granted post-conviction by furnishing appropriate security, especially when the punishment awarded is not of maximum severity and trial custody period plus other conditions justify suspension.
1) Civil Procedure – Interim Injunction – Requirements for grant of ex-parte ad-interim injunction include consideration of prima facie case, balance of convenience, and irreparable injury. 2) Procedural Law – Service of Documents – Proper service of plaint and motion notice is necessary to maintain fairness and natural justice before granting interim reliefs unless waived by respondents.
1) Criminal Procedure – Appeals – Prohibition of multiple appeals by same party against identical judgment to avoid multiplicity of litigation. 2) Criminal Jurisprudence – Finality of judgment – Preventing abuse of process by restricting duplicated appeals arising from the same order.
1) Criminal Procedure – Bail – Section 48 BNSS mandates communication of grounds of arrest to the arrested person and family member but substantial compliance without prejudice to the accused suffices. 2) Criminal Procedure – Bail – Pending investigation, bail may be denied if release risks prejudicing ongoing investigation, especially in cases involving serious offences and extended criminal networks.
1) Limitation Act, 1963 — Section 5 — Condonation of Delay — “Sufficient cause” must be construed liberally in a justice-oriented manner considering facts and circumstances — negligence of counsel may suffice as sufficient cause if litigant acted with reasonable diligence. 2) Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 — Order 43 Rule 1 — Appeal — Availability of statutory remedy of appeal under CPC is a near total bar to the exercise of jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution by the High Court in civil proceedings.
1) Jammu and Kashmir Prevention of Corruption Act, Svt. 2006 – Section 3 – Investigation – Police officers not below rank of Dy. SP competent to investigate corruption offences without prior Magistrate permission; Vigilance Organization given specialized powers but exclusive jurisdiction is not conferred thereby. 2) Indian Penal Code – Sections 464, 467, 468, 471 – Forgery – A document containing false assertions is not necessarily a false document; making a false document requires satisfying statutory elements which include dishonest or fraudulent making, signing or alteration.
1) Administrative Law – Section 5(1) of the PTCL Act – Mandate to consider stay applications filed against orders passed under the Act and the requirement of timely disposal of such applications. 2) Writ Jurisdiction – Scope of the writ of mandamus to compel an administrative authority to consider and decide a pending application within a reasonable time.
1) Guardian and Wards Act, 1890 – Section 9 – Jurisdiction – The jurisdiction of a Family Court in custody matters depends on the 'ordinary residence' of the minor, which is a question primarily of intention and fact requiring inquiry. 2) Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 – Order VII Rule 10 and Rule 11 – Procedure for return or rejection of plaint – Pleas on jurisdiction must be processed under Rule 10 through return of plaint, and not Rule 11 which deals with rejection on grounds like barred by law.
1) Execution Proceedings – Order for Sale of Attached Property – Court’s power to order sale upon failure of payment by judgment debtors – Execution courts have discretion to conduct sale unless payment is made before confirmation. 2) Civil Procedure Code – Execution – Section relating to payment and settlement during execution proceedings – Payment by judgment debtors at any stage before sale confirmation can lead to adjustment and withdrawal of sale proceedings.
1) Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 — Sections 7 and 13(1)(d) r/w 13(2) — Demand and acceptance of illegal gratification — Proof of demand and acceptance is sine qua non to establish offences under these sections and can be proved by direct oral, documentary, or circumstantial evidence. 2) Criminal Trial — Evaluation of Hostile Witness — Contradictions in complainant’s evidence do not necessarily discredit core allegations if other independent and corroborative evidence substantiate the demand and acceptance of bribe.
1) Property Law – Transfer of Property Act – Sale – Registration and Proof of Validity – Registered sale deed is prima facie evidence of valid transfer; onus shifts to challenger to rebut validity with cogent evidence. 2) Adverse Possession – Essential Ingredients – Possession must be hostile, continuous, open and unequivocal denial of true owner’s title; mere long possession without animus possidendi does not confer title.
1) Employees Compensation Act, 1923 – Section 30(a) – Right of appeal – The right to continue an appeal for compensation under the Employees Compensation Act survives in the legal representatives of the deceased injured employee. 2) Workmen’s Compensation – Assessment of Compensation – The compensation under the Employees Compensation Act is to be computed by applying the relevant multiplier to the monthly wages adjusted for the percentage of permanent disability, considering the age of the injured.
1) Criminal Procedure Code – Section 482 – Exercise of inherent powers by the High Court to grant anticipatory bail is discretionary and depends on the facts and stage of investigation. 2) Criminal Law – Excise Act, Section 34(2) – In offenses under special Acts, anticipatory bail is not a matter of right and custodial interrogation may be necessary depending on investigation requirements.
1) Criminal Procedure – Section 482 – Power of High Court to quash or prevent abuse of process – Anticipatory bail applications can be disposed of keeping in view facts like non-filing of charge-sheet and absence of arrest requisition. 2) Bail – Anticipatory Bail – Release on bail at pre-arrest stage should be considered with prudence and factual matrix; absence of formal proceedings or investigation steps weakens apprehension of arrest.
1) Criminal Procedure – Anticipatory Bail – Section 482 of Bhartiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 – Discretionary power of the Court to grant bail depends on the prima facie case and necessity of custodial interrogation. 2) Procedural Law – Police Investigation – Binding nature of Arnesh Kumar guidelines on police authorities for arrest and custodial interrogation to prevent unnecessary detention.
1) Criminal Procedure – BNSS, 2023, Section 35(3) – Mandates Investigating Officers to adhere to specific procedures, including verifying the necessity of arrest before detaining an accused. 2) Criminal Jurisprudence – Arnesh Kumar v. State of Bihar, (2014) 8 SCC 273 – Supreme Court guidelines emphasize strict compliance by police authorities with procedural safeguards against unnecessary arrests.
1) Criminal Procedure Code – Section 482 – The High Court’s inherent power under Section 482 cannot be exercised to grant anticipatory bail after the charge sheet for a Sessions triable offence has been filed and the bail application before the Sessions Court has been dismissed. 2) Criminal Procedure Code – Bail – An application for anticipatory bail can be lawfully withdrawn with liberty granted to the accused either to surrender or to apply for regular bail before the competent court, which must decide expeditiously.
1) Constitutional Law – Article 226 – Right to Protection – A major individual has the constitutional right to reside according to personal choice and live in a consensual live-in relationship, which the Court can protect from unlawful interference. 2) Domestic Violence Law – Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 – Live-in relationships are recognized under the Act, entitling partners to legal protection against domestic violence and coercion.
1) Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 – Sections 30, 31, 61 – The Adjudicating Authority and NCLAT have jurisdiction to approve, reject, or remand resolution plans but cannot interfere with the commercial decisions of the CoC or modify a resolution plan; the NCLAT may remit a plan to CoC to rectify non-compliance without substituting its commercial judgment. 2) Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 – Section 18 & Explanation (b) – Assets of any Indian or foreign subsidiary of a corporate debtor are excluded from the insolvency estate of the holding company, recognizing the separate legal personality and proprietary rights of subsidiaries.
1) Service Law – Probation and Termination – A probationer's service can be terminated without a formal inquiry if the termination is based on general unsuitability and not founded on proven misconduct, hence not punitive. 2) Service Law – Stigma in Termination – An order of termination carries stigma if it imputes misconduct or moral turpitude and is founded upon a formal inquiry resulting in a finding of guilt; mere administrative dissatisfaction does not constitute stigma.
1) National Investigation Agency Act, 2008 – Section 13(2) empowers transfer of cases to Special Courts for effective investigation and prosecution of connected offences. 2) Criminal Procedure – Consolidation or clubbing of cases is justified where common accused, overlapping evidence, and connected offences exist, to prevent multiplicity, conflicting findings, and ensure efficient trial.
1) Kerala Private Forests (Vesting and Assignment) Act, 1971 – Section 2(f) and Section 3(1) – Vesting of private forests in the State – Vesting is automatic on appointed day if land qualifies as private forest as defined under the Act. 2) Evidence – Appellate procedure – Admission of additional evidence – New evidence not produced despite due diligence cannot be admitted to fill lacunae or raise new case at appellate stage.
1) Service Law – Nagaland Excise Service (Revised) Rules, 1999 – The Rules authorize direct recruitment through “competitive examination/selection” without prescribing detailed procedural specifics, allowing recruitment boards discretion in conducting fair selection processes. 2) Administrative Law – Recruitment Procedure – A recruitment board, empowered under relevant advertisement clauses and government resolutions, may modify selection procedures mid-process where not expressly prohibited by Rules, provided fairness, transparency, and equal opportunity to candidates is maintained.
1) Service Law – Central Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1972, Rule 69(1)(c) prohibits payment of gratuity until conclusion of judicial proceedings and final orders. 2) Criminal Procedure Code, 1973 – Section 378 permits State to file leave petition against acquittal but acquittal remains binding until set aside.
1) Evidence – Appreciation – Appellate courts must not interfere with trial court findings based on appreciation of evidence unless there is a material irregularity, misreading, or inadmissible evidence. Mere doubt or suspicion is insufficient to overturn a considered judgment. 2) Civil Procedure – Standard of Proof – In civil cases, the standard is preponderance of probability, requiring a higher degree of possibility and a fair certainty of truth rather than proof beyond reasonable doubt.
1) Family Law – Maintenance – Interim maintenance can be enhanced by the Court based on the financial status, income, assets, and lifestyle of the liable party to ensure just and reasonable support. 2) Contempt of Court – Payment of court-ordered maintenance arrears is mandatory; non-compliance may attract contempt proceedings, subject to adequate opportunity and further orders of the Court.
1) Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 – Sections 2(30), 2(119), 9, 74, 122(2)(b) – A contract qualifies as a works contract attracting composite supply classification with higher GST rates only where the end product is immovable property as per the permanency and annexation tests applied on facts. 2) Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 – Section 168 and GST Council notifications – Clarifications and amendments prescribing GST rates and valuation mechanisms apply prospectively and provide options, not mandates, for retrospective application; invocation of penalty and extended limitation require clear proof of wilful misstatement or fraud.
1) Service Law – Disciplinary Action – Judicial Review – Interference justified where inquiry violates natural justice, statutory rules, or findings are arbitrary and unsupported by evidence. 2) Service Law – Punishment – Quantum of Penalty – Penalty is liable to be set aside if it is shockingly disproportionate to proven misconduct and shocks the conscience of the Court.