The Supreme Court on Wednesday said availability of
public toilets is an important duty of the state governments and Union
territories and steps need to be taken to ensure that such facilities are
accessible to all.
Issuing a slew of directions on a PIL filed by a
lawyer, the apex court asked all the high courts, state governments and UTs to
ensure availability of separate toilet facilities for males, females, persons
with disabilities (PwDs), and transgender persons in all court premises and
tribunals across the country.
A bench of Justices J B Pardiwala and R Mahadevan
while hearing the plea said public health is of paramount importance and
creation of adequate public toilets also protects the privacy and removes the
threat to women and transgender persons.
"The High Courts shall oversee and ensure that
these facilities are clearly identifiable and accessible to Judges, advocates,
litigants, and court staff.
"For the aforesaid purpose, a committee shall
be constituted in each of the High Courts under the chairmanship of a Judge
nominated by the Chief Justice and members comprising the Registrar
General/Registrar of the High Court, the Chief Secretary, the PWD Secretary and
the Finance Secretary of the State, a representative of the Bar Association and
any other officers as they deem it fit, within a period of six weeks," the
bench said.
The top court directed the committee to formulate a
comprehensive plan and have a statistic of number of persons visiting the
courts every day on an average and ensure that sufficient separate washrooms
are built and maintained.
It shall also conduct a survey regarding the
availability of toilet facilities, lacunae in the infrastructure and
maintenance of the same, the bench said.
"The State Governments / UTs shall allocate
sufficient funds for construction, maintenance and cleanliness of the toilet
facilities within the court premises, which shall be periodically reviewed in
consultation with the committee constituted by the High Courts. A status report
shall be filed by all the High Courts and the States/UTs within a period of
four months," the bench said.
The top court's judgement came on the PIL filed by
advocate Rajeeb Kalita seeking basic toilet facilities are made available in
all courts/ tribunals in the country for men, women, persons with disabilities,
and transgenders.
Observing that the right to life encompasses within
it the right to healthy and hygienic life and the right to live with dignity,
the apex court said, "Availability of access to public toilets is an
important duty of the States/UTs under the Directive Principles and it is just
not enough if such provisions are made but steps are to be taken to ensure that
the toilets are maintained throughout the year.
"Without such access to the three genders, the
States/UTs can no longer claim to be welfare State," the bench said.
It also expressed concern over condition of public
toilets built near toll plazas in the national highways across the country and
remarked it was seldom maintained and accessible.
"The need for toilets/washrooms/rest rooms is
even more acute for judges / advocates/ litigants/ staff members working in
large number in the Courts and Tribunals as they are mostly struck in one place
for longer periods because of the demands of the job and the system in the
function of the courts/Tribunals.
"Therefore, it is the duty of the Government
and local authorities to provide basic toilet and sanitation facilities within
the court premises and ensure that they are constructed, maintained and kept in
a hygienic condition for men, women, PwD, and transgender persons," the
bench said.
The court said toilets are not merely a matter of
convenience, but a basic necessity which is a facet of human rights.
"Access to proper sanitation is recognized as a
fundamental right under Article 21 of the Constitution, which guarantees the
right to life and personal liberty. This right inherently includes ensuring a
safe and hygienic environment for all individuals.
"There is a discernible duty on every State/UT
under Part IV of the Constitution to ensure a healthy environment and to
continuously strive of improving the public health. Access to justice includes
the creation of a pleasant and humanly atmosphere for all the stake holders in
the dispensation of justice," the bench said.
The litigants for fear of sitting in courts for long
hours without access to basic amenities should not be forced to refrain from
exercising their legal rights, it added.
The bench said high court premises must be equipped
with proper washroom facilities for judges, advocates, litigants and staff
members, just as required in other public places.
"Additionally, it is equally essential to
ensure that these facilities are adequately provided, maintained and accessible
to everyone, sans discomfort or inconvenience. As regards the District Courts,
we must also point out our deep concerns that there are instances where even
judges, particularly in rural areas, still lack access to proper washroom
facilities.
"This not only violates the rights of those
directly affected but also tarnishes the reputation of the judicial system,
which should serve as a model of fairness, dignity, and justice. The failure to
provide adequate washroom facilities is not just a logistical issue, but it
reflects a deeper flaw in the justice system. The sorry state of affairs
indicates the harsh reality that the judicial system faces," the bench
said.