The
Delhi High Court has opined that the six weeks' time given to women candidates,
who are pregnant at the time of a medical examination for appointment in the
Central Armed Police Forces (CAPF), to achieve the requisite fitness is
"extremely short" and asked authorities to examine the provision for
granting reasonable time.
The
high court said it may not be possible for a woman candidate, who has undergone
pregnancy, to regain her complete medical fitness and lose within six weeks the
weight gained during the nine months of her pregnancy.
The court was informed that according to paragraph
5.3 of the Guidelines of Recruitment Medical Examination in Central Armed
Police Forces and Assam Rifles, if a urine test for pregnancy is positive, the
candidate will be declared unfit temporarily and will be re-examined six weeks
after the pregnancy, subject to the production of a medical certificate of
fitness from a registered medical practitioner.
"This period of six weeks envisaged under the
guidelines to enable a female candidate to regain her medical fitness after
going through a pregnancy, in our considered opinion, is extremely short as it
may not always be possible for a female candidate, who has undergone a
pregnancy, to regain her complete medical fitness and lose the weight within
six weeks, which she may have gained during nine months of her pregnancy, as
even under the Maternity Benefit Act, 1961, a much longer period of absence
from duty has been envisaged," a bench of Justices Rekha Palli and
Shalinder Kaur said.
The
court directed the authorities concerned to examine this provision of the
guidelines in consultation with medical specialists to consider providing a
reasonable time within which a woman candidate is required to regain her
medical fitness after her pregnancy.
"The
matter, be therefore, placed before the additional director general (medical),
CAPF for this purpose," it said.
The
court was hearing a petition filed by a young mother, who aspired to join the
Sashastra Seema Bal (SSB) as a constable (washerman-female) under the Other
Backward Classes (OBC) quota, but was declared medically unfit on the ground of
being "overweight".
On
a query regarding the time granted to women candidates, who are pregnant at the
time of the medical examination, to achieve the requisite medical fitness, the
counsel for the authorities submitted that in all cases of pregnancy, six
weeks' time is granted to the candidates to attain the fitness.
It
was the woman's case that after clearing the written test, she appeared for the
medical examination when she was in the advanced stage of her pregnancy. Her
medical examination was deferred and she was directed to appear in the test
after her delivery.
The
plea said when the woman appeared before the medical board barely four months
after her delivery, she was declared "unfit" on the ground of being
overweight and even a review of the medical board declared her
"unfit" as her Body Mass Index (BMI) was found to be 25.3, which was
more than the acceptable limit of 25 prescribed for appointment in the CAPFs.
Being
dissatisfied with the findings, she approached a government hospital in Gwalior
where her BMI was found to be 24.8, but no action was taken by the authorities
after which she approached the high court for the relief.
The
bench said though it has no reasons to doubt the authorities' averment that the
woman's BMI was found to be more than 25 during the selection process, it has
to be taken into consideration that the candidate delivered a baby barely four
months before she was medically examined and that she deserved to be granted
another opportunity to be examined by a fresh medical board.
The court allowed the petition and directed that the
petitioner be examined within a week by a fresh medical board and if her BMI is
found to be less than 25, she would be appointed as a constable
(washerman-female) within four weeks.